Category Archives: Plaid Cymru

Plaid’s flexible manifesto

To what extent, if at all, does Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones exert control over Plaid Cymru, the party of which he is nominally the leader?

Plaid’s slender, 34-page manifesto was published today and contains at least two policies of which Mr Jones must surely disapprove.

First, Plaid reaffirm our opposition to the construction of any new nuclear power stations in Wales”.  Given that Mr Jones has enthusiastically welcomed the construction of Wylfa B in his Assembly constituency, one must wonder how he can put his name to such an apparently adamant statement of contrary principle. 

Second, the manifesto declares: 

We cannot tackle climate change without considering the impact of transport. The UK will not achieve its target of 80% carbon emission reductions by 2050 if air travel continues to expand… We call for the removal of hidden subsidies for air travel… 

Given Mr Jones’s strident support for the failed, heavily-subsidised Valley – Cardiff air link, one must assume that he held his nose while signing that policy off, too.

Or is it simply the case that Plaid are nothing more than a ragtag bunch of unprincipled chancers who are entirely relaxed about modifying their public stance to suit the audience they are addressing?

Elfyn in Coventry

The question burning on the lips of those few who care about these things is: what has become of Elfyn Llwyd?

Elfyn was, until dissolution yesterday, the leader of the three Plaid Cymru Members of Parliament.  He is, so far as I know, standing for election once again, in the newly created seat of Dwyfor Meirionnydd.  He consequently has a big stake in this election campaign and one might have expected Plaid to want to give him as much media exposure as possible.

However, since campaign started last week, there has been nary sight nor sound of Elfyn.  All Plaid’s press conferences have been fronted by the party’s Assembly leader, Ieuan Wyn Jones; he was at it again this morning, saying something or other about how terribly important Plaid is going to be when we have his longed-for “balanced” Parliament. 

But Elfyn was nowhere in evidence.  I know that Dwyfor is a glorious part of Wales, but surely he would, if asked, be prepared to abandon it briefly to make the journey to the BBC studio in Bangor.

The time has come to ask what heinous thought crime Elfyn has committed in the eyes of the Plaid establishment to be so sidelined.  Why has he been sent  to the Plaid equivalent of Coventry?  Is he soon to be expunged from memory as a Plaid non-person? 

For all that he can sometimes be a bit prickly, I really like Elfyn and I think we should be told.

Plaid’s absent friends

Plaid Cymru’s first campaign press conference was a particularly bizarre affair.  It featured the party’s Assembly leader, Ieuan Wyn Jones, and two fellow Assembly members, Helen Mary Jones and Elin Jones, none of whom, so far as I am aware, is seeking election to Parliament.

There was no sign of Plaid’s Parliamentary group leader, Elfyn Llwyd or, indeed, of any Parliamentary candidate.

Very odd.

Nuclear dilemma

I am delighted that Horizon Nuclear Power, a joint venture of the German energy companies E.ON and RWE, has announced its intention to build a new nuclear power station at Wylfa, Anglesey.  The station will not only help keep the lights on, but will also provide high quality jobs in the very poorest area of the United Kingdom.

My delight is shared, it would appear, by Ynys Môn’s Welsh Assembly member, Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones, who is also Plaid Cymru leader (or, at least, one of them).  Here’s how the Daily Post reports his reaction:

Ieuan Wyn Jones said the news was very welcome given the job losses suffered on the island during the previous 19 months.

“I will be working with Coleg Menai and Bangor University to ensure that we have the skills in place to ensure local people are best placed to secure jobs at the plant,” he said.

“Coleg Menai has set up a fabrication and engineering unit to train people for the new job opportunities that come up. We must now work with the company as they develop their plans to ensure that we maximise the economic benefit the project will bring to Anglesey, in terms of the jobs that it will create in the building and operational phases.

“Local business must also benefit from contracts on the site and from supply chain opportunities, and this will need to be built into any consents.”

Great to see such unequivocal enthusiasm from one of Plaid’s leadership triumvirate.  However, as this blog has previously noted, Mr Jones surely has a bit of an ethical dilemma here.  He, after all, signed off Plaid’s European election manifesto, which stoutly declared:

we reaffirm our total opposition to the construction of any new nuclear power stations in Wales.

Couldn’t be any clearer really, could it?  No wriggle room whatever there.  They even put it in bold print.

So what, we must ask, is Mr Jones going to do?   Will he be prostrating himself  in the path of the bulldozers as they attempt to cut the first sod?  Or will he be resigning his leadership of Plaid in the Assembly?

If he does neither, he will effectively be saying that Plaid’s anti-nuclear policy, for which he is personally responsible, doesn’t apply in his own little corner of Wales.

And that wouldn’t be right, would it?

Plaid up the pole

An article in today’s Daily Post has left me completely bemused:

THE Welsh Dragon flag will fly from Conwy Castle on St David’s Day despite ongoing problems with health and safety and seagull droppings.

Historic buildings and ancient monuments body Cadw, who took the flag down at the end of the summer tourist season as usual, say the castle has a particular problem with seagulls

Spikes were placed on its flagpoles to deter the birds, but fluttering cloth gets snagged on the spikes and rips.

A Cadw spokesman yesterday said it is costly to get specialist contractors to climb up and detach the remnants of the flag.

He said: “The flags are getting tangled and soiled and we are still working on a solution.

“But the Welsh Dragon flag goes up on important occasions and it will be up on St David’s Day.”

Plaid Cymru Conwy County councillor Phil Edwards is baffled why Conwy is a special case. “The Welsh Dragon can fly from other gusty landmarks like Caernarfon Castle and Harlech Castle. It’s ridiculous, given the brutality of Edward I towards the Welsh, that health and safety steps in 800 years on to prevent us pulling a flag up a pole.”

I really can’t understand the nature of Cllr Edwards’s gripe.  Cadw appear to be saying that the Red Dragon will be flying from the castle, despite the best efforts of the healthansafety brigade.

Fair play to him, however, for managing to get the obligatory anglophobic jibe in, no matter how abstruse the grounds.  Plaid will be proud of him.

Peter Hain should relax

A panicky-sounding Peter Hain is warning that Plaid Cymru could be contemplating dirty dealing after the election:

“Plaid could never form a government in Westminster, and all the signs emerging from their conference are that they would do a sordid deal with David Cameron.

“The Tories, propped up by Plaid, would be a change we in Wales cannot afford. The election this year will be a choice between a Labour government securing our economic recovery and jobs for Wales, or a Tory government putting everything at risk.”

Understandable anxiety, but I really do think that Peter ought to relax.

After all, most of  the sordid deals that Plaid have done to date have been with the Labour party.

Plaid Cymru’s principles

Arrived in London after a less than pleasant road journey and decided to watch The Politics Show on catch-up TV.

To my delight, it included a profile of the constituency of Ynys Môn, the scene of what is likely to be one of the most interesting Welsh contests in the forthcoming general election.

After interviews with the young and enthusiastic Conservative candidate, my friend  Anthony Ridge-Newman, the old independent warhorse, my friend Peter Rogers, and the incumbent Labour MP, my friend Albert Owen, there was a short exchange with the Plaid Cymru candidate, Mr Dylan Rees, with whom I am not yet acquainted.

Mr Rees was filmed standing outside RAF Valley, one of the few major employers on Anglesey.  Despite Plaid Cymru’s anti-military stance, Mr Rees seemed generally well disposed to the presence of the Royal Air Force on the island.

Mr Rees also spoke enthusiastically about the prospect of a replacement for Wylfa nuclear power station.  When it was put to him that Plaid disapproved of nuclear power, Mr Rees asked, rhetorically, how he could oppose a project that would bring up to 5,000 construction jobs and 1,000 permanent jobs.  To heck, he seemed to be saying, with policy.

Plaid Cymru’s blithe willingness to jettison apparently rigid political principle when it suits their purposes is a constant source of amusement.  The incumbent Welsh Assembly member for Ynys Môn, Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones (who happens to be Plaid’s leader in the Assembly), has also welcomed the replacement of Wylfa, despite having approved a manifesto which confirmed the party’s “total opposition to the construction of any new nuclear power stations in Wales”.

In adopting what might be most charitably described as a flexible approach to well-established party policy, therefore, Mr Rees is doing no more than following an equally well-established Plaid practice.

Welcome support from Plaid

Mr Ieuan Wyn Jones, the leader of Plaid Cymru in the Welsh Assembly, says that a hung Parliament would be “the best outcome for Wales”.

Nice to see that he is looking forward so eagerly to the prospect of substantial Tory gains, and I can assure him that we will be doing our very best to surpass even those  unexpected ambitions.

Vote for Plaid Orpington

Plaid Cymru leader in the Welsh Assembly, Ieuan Wyn Jones, has attracted considerable ridicule by “pledging to spend an extra £20bn a year on providing a ‘living pension’, as the party focuses on the general election”.

The problem, of course, is that Plaid are not going to win the next general election, unless they have plans of which I am unaware to put forward candidates in seats such as Orpington, York Outer and Glasgow Pollok and seek to persuade voters there that it would be in their interests to vote for a Welsh separatist party.  Even then, it would be a bit of a tall order.

If Mr Wyn Jones had said that in the event of a hung parliament, Plaid Cymru would require an increase in the state pension as a quid pro quo for supporting the governing party, people might have listened to him.

As it stands, however, he has simply made a twit of himself.

Libs and Plaid can’t be bothered

Labour is not the only party falling to bits in Westminster.

Today the Draft Local Government (Wales) Measure 2009 (Consequential Modifications) Order 2009 went through committee; I had the privilege of leading for Her Majesty’s loyal opposition.

Now, I know that the Order wasn’t the most riveting piece of Parliamentary business ever (even as I type those words I’m bracing myself for the inevitable wrath of Gwenda Thomas), but you’d have thought that both the Lib Dems and Plaid Cymru would be sufficiently interested to go to the trouble of sending someone along. 

Those empty seats really didn’t look good.

Welcome, Mohammad

I am delighted to welcome the former Plaid Cymru Assembly member, Mohammad Ashgar and his daughter, Natasha, a former Plaid European candidate, to the Conservative party.

Mr Ashgar told a news conference today that he felt “out of tune” with Plaid policies, in particular its desire for an independent Wales, and believes in “the Royal family and one United Kingdom”.

In other words, Mr Ashgar considers Plaid to be a subversive, separatist party that wants to break up our country and render Wales an insignificant province of a European superstate.  Which, of course, it is.

I am sure that Mr Ashgar will soon find himself completely at home in the Conservative party, which wholly reflects his own values.

The Loyal Address

The debate on the Queen’s speech is one of the great set-pieces of the Parliamentary year.  Yesterday, the Loyal Address was proposed by Frank Dobson, the veteran MP for Holborn and St Pancras, who is both delightfully unreconstructed Old Labour and a very kind man (he once offered to buy me a coffee when I found myself without funds at the Portcullis House coffee shop).

Frank’s speech was extremely funny; the following story about his predecessor, Lena Jeger, gives a flavour:

She used to retell the tale that at her by-election in 1953 she was canvassing the top flat of a block in Camden Town. She launched into the great left-wing issue of the day—German rearmament and the threat it posed to international security. She stopped for breath, and the woman at the door asked, “Did you come up in the lift?”, and Lena says, “Yes.” “Stinks of pee, doesn’t it?” says the woman. “Yes,” says Lena. “Can’t you stop ’em peeing in our lift?” says the woman. “I don’t think I can,” says Lena. “Well,” says the woman, “if you can’t stop ’em peeing in our lift, how can you expect me to believe you can stop the Germans rearming?” A timeless lesson for us all.

The chamber was, of course, very full for the opening of the debate.  As a consequence, I found myself sitting on the furthermost back benches, behind the DUP and the small contingent from Plaid Cymru and the SNP.

David Cameron opened his contribution by congratulating Frank Dobson and Emily Thornberry, the Labour MP who had seconded the Loyal Address.  He then went on to welcome William Bain, the new Labour Member for Glasgow North-East, who had just taken his seat:

I expect that we will see the hon. Gentleman back in the House after the next election. I am sure there are many things that we will disagree about, but one thing on which I hope we will always agree is that we should never do anything to break up our United Kingdom.

At that point, one of the Plaid Cymru MPs dug his SNP neighbour in the ribs; they glanced at each other and both sniggered. 

It was a telling moment.

Nuclear reactors

There must be something about the sea air on Anglesey: it miraculously turns even the most hardened opponent of nuclear power into an enthusiast for a new generating station at Wylfa.

The Damascene conversion of Plaid Cymru’s Welsh Assembly leader, Ieuan Wyn Jones, is already well known.  Plaid Cymru is deeply anti-nuclear; its 2009 Euro manifesto confirmed its “total opposition to the construction of any new nuclear power stations in Wales” and its Assembly spokeswoman, Leanne Wood, declared in a plenary debate in September, 2007, that:

“Plaid Cymru, under all circumstances, will oppose any future proposal to locate a new nuclear power station at Wylfa”

Mr Jones was accordingly very much out of step with his own party when, in January 2008, he enthusiastically welcomed the Government’s announcement of its commitment to a new generation of nuclear power stations as “good news”. 

Mr Jones admittedly is the Assembly member for Anglesey, and Wylfa is a major employer there, but nevertheless it is rather odd to see a party leader putting his name to a manifesto policy which he manifestly considers to be a load of old cobblers.

Now Carwyn Jones has also experienced the Wylfa effect.

Mr Jones is one of three candidates for the leadership of the Labour group in the Welsh Assembly.  He visited Anglesey yesterday as part of his campaign tour and announced that, as the debate on nuclear energy had “shifted considerably”, he now believed that nuclear power will form part of Wales’s low-carbon response to the serious challenges we face in the years to come”.

Mr Jones’s dramatic turnabout will, I am sure, please the local MP, Albert Owen, who is staunchly pro-nuclear and has put his name to Mr Jones’s nomination papers.

It may, however, be less pleasing to another of his sponsors, the Welsh environment minister, Jane Davidson.  Ms Davidson has always strongly adhered to the official Assembly Government line (to which Mr Jones is still nominally committed) of opposition to new nuclear development in Wales.  Only two months ago, she demanded a public inquiry into the Government’s proposals for Wylfa B “on the grounds of concern over the safety and security of the management of future nuclear waste”.

Ms Davidson may now be wondering whether she has backed the right man.  Perhaps she, too, should take a trip up to Anglesey and breathe the balmy Wylfa air.

Not different enough

Speaking of the Lib Dems, Nick Clegg is apparently due to tell delegates at his party’s conference:

“If you want things to be different, really different, you have to choose different. That’s our message.”

Unfortunately, in Wales, that’s Plaid Cymru’s message, too.

Still silence from Plaid

Saddo that I am, I couldn’t resist breaking into the first day of my holiday to see if Plaid Cymru’s press officers had put any more of the conference speeches up on their website.

I was disappointed; still nothing at 10.30 BST. 

I was intrigued, however, to see that the outgoing deputy Chief Constable of North Wales Police, Clive Wolfendale, was scheduled to speak.  I wonder what he said?